Complete "Lesson 26: Micro WTI Demo Lab" first to unlock this lesson.Go to previous lesson

In this thirteen-minute beginner lesson, learners build and audit a trading journal using the entirely fictional Sample Micro Oil futures contract from Lesson 26. The objective is to document simulated spread, slippage, partial fills, commissions, margin changes, gap risk, and rule-following rather than predict market prices. The learner begins with a dated specification from April 1, 2026, an updated margin notice from April 15, and a simulated trade on April 20. A $10,000 paper account permits $100 of planned risk. Two micro contracts are initially planned at $70.02 with a $69.62 stop and $70.82 target, producing $83 planned risk and $157 planned net target profit. Actual partial entry fills at $70.04 and $70.06 produce a $70.05 average, creating $6 entry slippage and increasing planned stop risk to $89. An actual exit at $70.80 creates $4 additional execution shortfall, reducing realized simulated net profit to $147. Learners then stress updated margin requirements, examine a hypothetical stop gap that creates a $153 net loss, and summarize five simulated trades with $66 combined net profit, $18 slippage costs and $15 commissions. The lesson finishes with a reproducible one-page trade journal, a rule-following review, and an explanation of why five results cannot establish a reliable strategy. Every product, contract, quotation and trading outcome is fictional; all money is simulated, and no investment advice or price prediction is provided.

Why a Trading Journal Records Decisions Before Outcomes

A trading journal is a chronological record of what a learner intended to do, what actually happened, and whether the process followed a written policy. It is not simply a table of profits and losses. A useful journal preserves the information available before an order, including contract specifications, entry and exit rules, risk limits, displayed quotations, and the reasons for choosing or rejecting a simulated setup. After execution, it adds actual fills, costs, revised risk and review notes. Keeping those stages separate helps reveal execution mistakes and protects against hindsight bias. A profitable outcome does not prove that a decision was well controlled, and a losing outcome does not automatically establish that the process was incorrect.

Beginner reviewing a fictional trading journal
Figure 1. A learner reviews a fictional trading journal.

Continue with the entirely fictional Sample Micro Oil futures contract introduced in Lesson 26. The specification dated April 1, 2026 defines 100 barrels per contract, a $0.01 minimum price tick, a $1 tick value, and commission of $0.75 per contract per side. Its original margin amounts were $600 initial and $540 maintenance per contract. A later fictional notice dated April 15 changes those amounts to $700 initial and $630 maintenance. The simulated trading date is Monday, April 20, 2026. The last trading day is Tuesday, May 19, leaving 29 calendar days. Record both document dates, the source and the effective margin notice before analyzing the transaction.

Dated futures specification and revised margin notice
Figure 2. Dated specification and margin notice documents.
The plan: entry $70.02, stop $69.62, target $70.82.
Figure 3. The plan: entry $70.02, stop $69.62, target $70.82.

Key points

  • A journal records the plan, the quote and every fill before the outcome is known; a win can hide poor execution and a loss can follow a good plan.
  • Record the spec date (2026-04-01), the margin notice date (2026-04-15), equity $10,000 and 29 days to the May 19 last trading day.
  • The written plan: buy 2 at the $70.02 ask, stop $69.62 (40 ticks), target $70.82 (80 ticks), planned risk $83 (0.83%), planned net +$157.
Journal header and plan
FieldValueSource
Spec version2026-04-01Spec sheet
Margin notice2026-04-15Notice
Equity$10,000Account
Entry / stop / target70.02 / 69.62 / 70.82Plan
Planned risk$83 (0.83%)Plan
Planned net at target+$157Plan

The simulated account has $10,000 starting equity and a written risk-per-trade budget of 1%, or $100. The plan is to buy two contracts at a displayed ask of $70.02, stop at $69.62 and target $70.82. The 40-tick stop across two contracts represents $80 gross price risk; the completed round-trip commission adds $3. Thus initial planned risk is $83, equal to 0.83% of equity. The target is 80 ticks above entry and provides $160 planned gross profit, or $157 after commission. This pretrade record becomes the baseline against which all later fills and execution shortfalls are measured.

Trade plan recorded before execution
Figure 4. The written trade plan, recorded before the order.
The written plan table, with $83 planned risk.
Figure 5. The written plan table, with $83 planned risk.

Capture the Order-Time Quote, Spread and Partial Fills

Immediately before placing the fictional market buy, record the displayed bid of $70.00 and ask of $70.02. Their midpoint is $70.01, and the quoted spread is $0.02 per barrel, or two price ticks. The product represents 100 barrels per contract, so the spread difference is $2 for one contract and $4 across two. The displayed ask sits one tick above the midpoint. Across two contracts, that one-tick difference represents $2 of entry execution friction measured against the midpoint. This midpoint comparison is not the same as slippage and should not be labeled or added to subsequent costs without identifying the reference price used.

The quote at order time: bid $70.00, ask $70.02, mid $70.01.
Figure 6. The quote at order time: bid $70.00, ask $70.02, mid $70.01.

The simulated market buy fills in two separate parts: one contract at $70.04 and another at $70.06. Because the quantities are equal, the weighted average fill is ($70.04 plus $70.06) divided by two, or $70.05. If quantities differed, the calculation would multiply each fill price by its quantity before dividing by total executed contracts. A journal that records only the original order price of $70.02 would miss what the position actually cost. Record both partial execution prices, contract quantities, average fill and the original quotation. The full execution evidence should remain intact rather than replacing the plan with the final average.

Half-spread and slippage use different baselines.
Figure 7. Half-spread and slippage use different baselines.

Key points

  • Record bid $70.00, ask $70.02 and mid $70.01 when the order is sent; the spread is 2 ticks, $2 per contract, $4 for two.
  • The entry half-spread (ask minus mid) is 1 tick = $2; slippage is measured against the ask you saw, so the two use different baselines.
  • A market buy fills 1 at $70.04 and 1 at $70.06; the average is $70.05, which is 3 ticks above the ask: slippage 3 x $1 x 2 = $6.
Spread versus slippage
CostBaselineTicksDollars
Half-spreadMidpoint1$2
Full spreadBid to ask2$4
Entry slippageAsk seen3$6

Entry slippage is measured against the ask observed when the market buy was sent. The weighted average execution of $70.05 is $0.03 above the $70.02 observed ask, or three ticks worse. With two contracts each worth $1 per tick, the slippage costs $6. That is separate from the $2 entry half-spread measured against the $70.01 midpoint. Both describe different aspects of execution, but their reference points differ. The complete bid-ask spread is not a separately billed fee and must not be deducted again from profit or loss already computed using actual fills. In the journal, store both the benchmark quotation and the corresponding execution comparison.

Two partial fills average $70.05.
Figure 8. Two partial fills average $70.05.
Entry slippage: 3 ticks, or $6.
Figure 9. Entry slippage: 3 ticks, or $6.

Recalculate Stop Risk After the Actual Entry

The original planned entry was $70.02, and the intended stop remained $69.62. That was a 40-tick distance and produced $83 commission-inclusive planned loss for two contracts. However, the actual entry is $70.05. Keeping the stop unchanged increases the distance to $70.05 minus $69.62, or $0.43 per barrel. This is 43 ticks rather than 40. The journal must update risk using the executed entry price rather than continue displaying the original risk as though the fill had not changed. The original plan should still remain visible as a separate field for comparison.

Planned risk: $83, or 0.83% of equity.
Figure 10. Planned risk: $83, or 0.83% of equity.

At two contracts, the combined price sensitivity is $2 per tick. Forty-three ticks therefore represent $86 of gross price loss if the stop later fills exactly at $69.62. Add the $3 round-trip commission to obtain $89 of updated commission-inclusive risk. Relative to $10,000 starting equity, this equals 0.89%, remaining below the written $100 budget. The increase from the original $83 planned risk is precisely $6, matching the three-tick entry slippage across two contracts. The journal should label the $89 as updated planned risk under exact-stop assumptions, not an unconditional maximum possible realized loss.

Updated stop risk from the actual fill: $89.
Figure 11. Updated stop risk from the actual fill: $89.

Key points

  • From the actual $70.05 fill to the $69.62 stop is 43 ticks: 43 x $2 = $86 plus $3 commission = $89 (0.89%).
  • That is $6 above the planned $83 but still under the $100 budget.
  • Never overwrite the plan with the actual fill; keep both so execution quality stays visible.
Planned versus actual risk
ItemPlannedActual
Entry$70.02$70.05 average
Stop distance40 ticks43 ticks
Risk with commission$83 (0.83%)$89 (0.89%)
Budget$100$100

This distinction is important because the size was originally selected using a valid policy, yet execution changed the economics after the order was submitted. A market order can fill at multiple prices, and a protective stop may execute beyond its trigger during volatility or gaps. The journal therefore records both compliance at planning time and compliance after execution. If the updated risk exceeded the written budget, the learner would need to flag the simulated policy breach rather than quietly edit the initial entry assumption. A consistent record separates trade design, actual execution, and subsequent market risks. It provides evidence about the process without guaranteeing that the trade can always be controlled within a fixed amount.

Planned against actual: entry, stop risk and net.
Figure 12. Planned against actual: entry, stop risk and net.

Reconcile Actual Net P&L and Execution Shortfall

The fictional target remains $70.82, and the simulated exit begins when the displayed bid shows that level. However, the market sell executes at $70.80, two ticks worse than the observed exit bid. The resulting shortfall is two ticks multiplied by the two-contract combined tick value of $2, or $4. Record the displayed bid and the actual fill separately, just as with the entry. The executed entry averaged $70.05, so the actual favorable difference is $70.80 minus $70.05, or $0.75 per barrel. Multiplying by 100 barrels per contract and two contracts gives $150 gross profit.

Actual net result: +$147, or +1.47%.
Figure 13. Actual net result: +$147, or +1.47%.

The fictional commission remains $0.75 per contract per side. Buying two contracts costs $1.50, and closing two costs another $1.50, giving $3 round-trip commission. Actual net profit is $150 minus $3, or $147. Relative to $10,000 starting account equity, that is positive 1.47%. The original plan expected $160 gross and $157 net at the displayed entry ask and target bid. The difference between planned net and actual net is $157 minus $147, or $10. The reduction is completely explained by the $6 adverse entry slippage and $4 adverse exit execution shortfall, with identical commission assumptions in both calculations.

Execution shortfall: $6 entry plus $4 exit is $10.
Figure 14. Execution shortfall: $6 entry plus $4 exit is $10.

Key points

  • The market sell fills at $70.80 when the bid showed $70.82: 2 ticks worse, $4.
  • Actual gross = (70.80 - 70.05) x 200 = +$150; minus $3 commission = +$147 net (+1.47%).
  • Shortfall = planned $157 - actual $147 = $10 = $6 entry + $4 exit. Do not subtract the spread again.
Net result and shortfall
LineCalculationResult
Actual gross(70.80 - 70.05) x 200+$150
Commission2 x 2 x 0.75$3
Actual net150 - 3+$147 (+1.47%)
Planned net160 - 3+$157
Shortfall157 - 147$10
Where the $10 shortfall came from ($)
$6
Entry slippage
$4
Exit shortfall

Execution shortfall is an attribution exercise, not an additional charge to subtract after actual net profit has already been calculated. The $147 net result already reflects actual entry and exit execution prices, plus commission. Deducting the $10 shortfall again would double-count the effect. Similarly, subtracting the quoted bid-ask spread separately would double-count execution-side pricing embedded in gross P&L. The journal should show planned gross, planned commission, planned net, observed quotations, actual fills, actual gross, actual commission, actual net, and the difference between the two net results. This permits an audit of execution quality without mixing price movement, spread, slippage and explicitly billed fees.

Document Margin Requirements and a Margin-Increase Stress

The original April 1 fictional specification showed initial margin of $600 and maintenance margin of $540 per contract. The April 15 notice raised those requirements to $700 and $630. Because the simulated trade occurs April 20, the updated numbers apply. Two contracts therefore require $1,400 initial margin, or 14% of the original $10,000 account equity. The updated maintenance requirement is two multiplied by $630, or $1,260. These amounts should appear in separate journal fields. Initial margin concerns the collateral needed to establish the position, while maintenance margin describes a lower continuing requirement under the assumed rules.

Margin used after the notice: $1,400, with $1,260 maintenance.
Figure 15. Margin used after the notice: $1,400, with $1,260 maintenance.

The simple free-equity calculation is $10,000 minus $1,400, leaving $8,600 before commissions, market P&L and other commitments. Now introduce a hypothetical further increase of 25% in the initial margin requirement. Per-contract initial margin rises from $700 to $875, so the same two-contract position requires $1,750. This equals 17.5% of the starting $10,000 account, and simplified free equity becomes $8,250. The increase reduces the calculated available amount by $350. The fictional stress does not specify another maintenance margin change, so do not invent one. Record the stress as an assumption rather than a new official margin notice.

Margin across three versions: used and free equity.
Figure 16. Margin across three versions: used and free equity.

Key points

  • After the notice, margin for two contracts is 2 x $700 = $1,400 (14%) and maintenance 2 x $630 = $1,260; free equity $8,600.
  • Stress: initial margin +25% is $875 per contract, 2 x 875 = $1,750 (17.5%), free equity $8,250.
  • Margin changes do not change tick value; they change collateral and pressure.
Margin versions
CasePer contractTwo contractsFree equity
Apr 1 sheet$600$1,200 (12%)$8,800
Apr 15 notice$700$1,400 (14%)$8,600
Stress +25%$875$1,750 (17.5%)$8,250

Margin requirements influence available collateral and the possibility of margin calls or forced actions, but changing the initial margin does not alter the contract's fixed $2 combined tick sensitivity. This difference between collateral and notional exposure follows the earlier margin and leverage lessons. The journal should preserve initial and maintenance requirements, their document dates, the number of contracts, margin used, the simplified remaining equity and any stress assumptions. Real futures clearing and brokerage arrangements can involve additional margin calculations, settlement cash flows, restrictions and changes. The demonstration is therefore a teaching model, not a complete statement of actual withdrawable funds or a guaranteed liquidation threshold.

Stress: initial margin up 25% is $1,750.
Figure 17. Stress: initial margin up 25% is $1,750.

Stress-Test a Stop Gap Beyond the Written Risk Budget

An intended stop is a plan for responding to adverse price movement, not an assurance that a market order will execute at the specified price. Consider a separate fictional adverse scenario in which the price gaps through the $69.62 stop and the position eventually closes at $69.30. Use the actual $70.05 average entry, not the original intended $70.02 entry. The difference is negative $0.75 per barrel. Across 200 barrels, gross P&L is negative $150. This represents a substantially larger adverse movement than the 43-tick distance between the actual entry and original stop.

Gap exit at $69.30: net -$153, or -1.53%.
Figure 18. Gap exit at $69.30: net -$153, or -1.53%.

The hypothetical stop exit is a normal two-contract closing transaction, so the same $3 completed-round-trip commission applies. Net loss becomes $150 plus $3 in costs, or $153. Relative to the $10,000 account, the loss is 1.53%. Compared with the original $83 commission-inclusive planned risk, the realized loss is $153 divided by $83, approximately 1.84 times the initial amount. Compared with the written $100 budget, the $153 loss is 1.53 times as large and exceeds that budget by $53. The figures illustrate why planned sizing can reduce intended exposure without guaranteeing that realized losses remain within the original amount.

Planned stop, actual stop and gap exit compared.
Figure 19. Planned stop, actual stop and gap exit compared.

Key points

  • If price gaps through the stop and the position closes at $69.30: (69.30 - 70.05) x 200 = -$150, net -$153 (-1.53%).
  • That is 1.84 times the planned $83 and 1.53 times the $100 budget.
  • A stop is an intended exit, not a guaranteed loss limit; record the gap assumption.
Stop versus gap
ExitPriceNetOf equity
Planned stop$69.62-$830.83%
Actual stop$69.62-$890.89%
Gap exit$69.30-$1531.53%
Net loss by exit ($)
-$83
Planned stop
-$89
Actual stop
-$153
Gap exit

The gap scenario is not a prediction, a typical-loss estimate or a claim about actual oil-market frequency. It demonstrates a failure mode that a journal should explicitly document. Record the stop trigger, the assumed execution price, the price gap, the total gross and net loss, and the multiple of planned risk. Mark the budget as breached under this hypothetical outcome, even though the original position sizing complied with the written rule. Additional operational problems, trading interruptions, widened spreads and account-level collateral rules could complicate real execution further. The appropriate educational lesson is to preserve uncertainty in risk estimates rather than present a stop price as a guaranteed financial boundary.

Review Five Simulated Trades Without Claiming an Edge

Extend the journal with five entirely fictional two-contract trades, each already expressed as net P&L after commission. Their results are positive $147, negative $85, positive $62, negative $89 and positive $31. Adding them produces a net total of $66. Dividing by five gives an average of $13.20 per trade, equal to 0.132% of the original $10,000 account equity. Three trades are profitable and two are losing, producing a 60% win rate. The winning results total $240, so average win is $80. The two losing results total $174 in absolute value, making average loss $87. These summary statistics describe only the invented five-trade sample.

Total friction: $18 slippage plus $15 commission is $33.
Figure 20. Total friction: $18 slippage plus $15 commission is $33.

Now measure execution costs using a separate journal field. The five recorded slippage amounts are 3, 1, 2, 3 and 0 ticks, for nine ticks total and 1.8 ticks on average per trade. In this simplified summary, each tick represents an aggregate two-contract execution shortfall worth $2. Therefore slippage totals $18. Each trade pays $3 round-trip commission, giving $15 across five trades. Combined measured costs are $33. Adding these costs back to the $66 net result yields a hypothetical $99 P&L before slippage and commission. Costs therefore consumed $33 divided by $99, or approximately 33.3%, of that frictionless comparison.

Five-trade review: costs and net result.
Figure 21. Five-trade review: costs and net result.

Key points

  • Five trades, nets +$147, -$85, +$62, -$89, +$31: sum +$66, average +$13.20, 3 wins of 5 (60%), average win $80, average loss $87.
  • Slippage ticks 3, 1, 2, 3, 0 = 9 ticks, $18; commission 5 x $3 = $15; total costs $33.
  • Frictionless total $99, so costs took 33.3%. Five trades prove very little: review process, not prediction.
Five-trade journal
LineCalculationResult
Net total147 - 85 + 62 - 89 + 31+$66
Average66 / 5+$13.20
Slippage9 ticks x $2$18
Commission5 x $3$15
Before costs66 + 18 + 15$99
Costs share33 / 9933.3%
Net result per trade ($)
+$147
Trade 1
-$85
Trade 2
+$62
Trade 3
-$89
Trade 4
+$31
Trade 5

A five-trade sample is far too small to establish a reliable strategy, expected return, win probability or future performance. The frictionless figure is a mechanical comparison based on the recorded slippage and fee assumptions, not a tradable result guaranteed to occur without those costs. The learner should concentrate on whether prices and contract quantities were recorded correctly, whether the latest margin notice was applied, whether original plans were preserved, and whether losing or rejected setups were logged. A useful process review can reveal missing data, repeated execution difficulties and breaches of written rules. It cannot transform five fictional trades into statistical evidence of a profitable trading method.

Complete the One-Page Journal and Establish a Review Routine

The one-page journal begins with identification and pretrade fields: simulated date, fictional product, specification version, applicable margin notice, contract size, tick value, expiry deadline, account equity, written risk rule, contract count, observed bid and ask, intended entry, stop, target and planned profit or loss. The order-time quote must be retained so slippage can be calculated against what was visible when the order was submitted. The execution section lists each partial-fill quantity and price, the weighted average entry, exit-side quotation, actual exit fill, gross P&L, explicit commissions, slippage and net P&L. Planned and actual figures belong in different columns.

The one-page journal record.
Figure 22. The one-page journal record.

Practice Lab: Audit a Fictional Micro Oil Trading Journal

Use the fictional Sample Micro Oil futures product and simulated money only. Record the April 1, 2026 specification, April 15 margin notice, April 20 trade date, and May 19 last trading day. Write the original plan before the simulated order: two contracts, $70.02 entry, $69.62 stop, $70.82 target, $83 planned risk, $157 planned target net and a $100 budget. Save the entry quote of $70.00 bid and $70.02 ask, then calculate the actual average entry from one fill at $70.04 and another at $70.06. Record slippage against the observed ask separately from spread measured against the midpoint. Recalculate risk with the actual entry, reconcile the $70.80 exit and $147 net result, and attribute the $10 execution shortfall. Document updated initial and maintenance margin, a further 25% hypothetical initial-margin increase and a separate $69.30 gap-stop stress. Finish by reviewing the five net results, slippage and commission totals, and whether the process followed its written rules. Use a paper worksheet or isolated mock platform; no live order or real account is necessary.

  • Decision 1: The fictional specification is dated April 1, 2026, a margin notice is dated April 15, the paper trade occurs Monday April 20, and the last trading day is Tuesday May 19. Account equity is $10,000. — What information must the journal preserve before the order, which margin notice applies, and how many calendar days remain before the last trading day?
  • Decision 2: The planned long buys two contracts at displayed ask $70.02, with bid $70.00, midpoint $70.01, stop $69.62, target $70.82 and $3 round-trip commission. The actual buy fills one contract at $70.04 and one at $70.06. — Calculate the weighted average fill, spread, entry half-spread, entry slippage, original planned risk and updated exact-stop risk.
  • Decision 3: The intended target exit bid is $70.82, but a simulated market sell fills both contracts at $70.80. Actual entry was $70.05, and completed round-trip commission is $3. — Calculate actual gross and net P&L, exit shortfall, total execution shortfall and percentage of starting equity.
  • Decision 4: The current margin notice requires $700 initial and $630 maintenance per contract. A hypothetical additional 25% increase affects initial margin only. Separately, a price gap causes the two-contract long entered at $70.05 to exit at $69.30. — Calculate current and stressed margins, remaining simplified equity, gap loss and how far that loss exceeds the written budget.
  • Decision 5: Five fictional two-contract trades produce net P&L of +$147, -$85, +$62, -$89 and +$31. Their slippage totals 3, 1, 2, 3 and 0 position ticks, and each completed round trip pays $3 commission. — Calculate net total, average P&L, win rate, average win, average loss, slippage costs, total costs and frictionless comparison, then state what cannot be inferred.

Answer key

Check your answers
DecisionAnswerHorizonReason
#1Record product and specification source, April 1 version, April 15 notice, April 20 trade date, account equity, contract units, tick value, initial and maintenance margin, expiry and written risk budget. The April 15 notice applies, setting initial margin at $700 and maintenance at $630 per contract. May 19 is 29 calendar days after April 20.Before the simulated April 20 orderThe later dated notice supersedes the original margin values, and the two specified calendar dates are 29 days apart.
#2The weighted average entry is $70.05. Quoted spread is two ticks, or $4 across two contracts. The entry half-spread versus the $70.01 midpoint is one tick, or $2. Entry slippage against the observed $70.02 ask is three ticks, or $6. Initial planned stop risk is $83 including commission; updated stop risk from $70.05 to $69.62 is $86 price loss plus $3 commission, or $89.Order submission, partial fills and post-entry risk updateEqual contract quantities give a simple average of the two fill prices, while slippage and stop risk use the observed ask and actual weighted entry respectively.
#3Actual gross profit is ($70.80 - $70.05) × 200 = $150. After $3 commission, net profit is $147, or 1.47% of starting equity. Exit shortfall is two ticks × $2 = $4. Planned net was $157, so total execution shortfall is $10, comprising $6 adverse entry slippage and $4 exit shortfall.Simulated completed trade reconciliationThe actual fill difference generates $150 gross P&L, and the two execution differences explain the full $10 reduction from planned net.
#4Current initial margin is $1,400 and maintenance is $1,260; simplified free equity is $8,600. Stressed initial margin becomes $875 per contract, or $1,750 total, leaving $8,250. The gap produces $150 gross loss and $153 net loss after commission, or 1.53% of equity. This is approximately 1.84 times the original $83 planned risk and exceeds the $100 budget by $53.Independent margin-increase and gap-risk stressesMargin scales with the specified per-contract requirements, while gap P&L uses the $0.75 adverse price movement across 200 barrels.
#5Net total is +$66, average +$13.20 per trade or 0.132% of starting equity. Three wins give a 60% win rate. Average win is $80, and average loss magnitude is $87. Nine ticks of slippage cost $18; commissions total $15, so combined costs are $33. Hypothetical P&L before those costs is $99, and costs equal 33.3% of that result. Five simulated trades cannot establish a reliable trading edge or predict future returns.Five-trade fictional journal reviewThe calculations aggregate the stated net outcomes and execution costs, while the extremely small sample prevents reliable performance inference.

Add a risk section that compares the $83 originally planned stop risk with the $89 updated exact-stop risk after the $70.05 entry. Record current $1,400 initial margin, $1,260 maintenance margin and simplified $8,600 available equity before costs. Include the hypothetical 25% additional margin increase, resulting in $1,750 initial margin and $8,250 remaining equity. Document the separate $153 gap-loss scenario and its 1.84 multiple of initial planned risk. Keep hypothetical stress results visibly distinct from actual simulated trade outcomes, and mark whether each scenario respects the written budget. Expiry notes should state the 29-day countdown and any later review date.

Key points

  • One page: dates and versions, plan, quote, fills, slippage, actual risk, net, shortfall, margin used and stress, rule-following tag.
  • Common mistakes: journal after the fact, no quote recorded, ignored partial fills, old margin, judging by one trade, hiding bad trades.
  • Practice logging a trade on a demo platform with simulated money only.
One-page demo journal
SectionRecord
DatesSpec, notice, trade date, days to expiry
PlanEntry, stop, target, size, risk, budget
QuoteBid, ask, spread in ticks
FillsAverage price, slippage in ticks and dollars
ResultActual risk, net, shortfall
MarginUsed, free equity, stress
ReviewRule-following tag and notes

Finish with a brief rule-following tag and a regular review process. Record whether the original specification was current, the planned risk met the policy, the fill was documented completely, the margin assumptions were checked, and execution costs were reconciled without double-counting. Include rejected setups and losing trades, rather than selecting only successful examples. At review time, calculate a small set of descriptive measures, identify missing information and avoid claiming statistical certainty. This lesson connects the XAUUSD sizing lab, Micro Oil demonstration, spread and slippage principles, and margin-and-leverage concepts. The next Risk Review Clinic preparation will audit contract specifications, minimum-size constraints and slippage assumptions using the same disciplined documentation approach.

Worked example at a glance

Trading Journal and Execution Risk: One Fictional Micro Oil Trade
Specification, plan, fills and execution reconciliationMargin, gap risk, five-trade review and journal fields
Product: Sample Micro Oil futures, entirely fictionalOriginal initial margin per contract: $600
Specification version: 2026-04-01Original maintenance per contract: $540
Updated margin notice: 2026-04-15Updated initial margin per contract: $700
Simulated trading date: Monday, 2026-04-20Updated maintenance per contract: $630
Last trading day: Tuesday, 2026-05-19Updated initial margin used: 2 × $700 = $1,400
Days remaining: 29 calendar daysInitial margin as percentage of equity: $1,400 / $10,000 × 100 = 14%
Contract size: 100 barrels per contractUpdated total maintenance requirement: 2 × $630 = $1,260
Price tick: $0.01 per barrelSimplified free equity before costs: $10,000 - $1,400 = $8,600
Tick value per contract: 100 × $0.01 = $1.00Hypothetical additional margin increase: 25% of $700 initial margin
Position: 2 contracts = 200 barrelsStressed initial margin per contract: $700 × 1.25 = $875
Combined tick value: 2 × $1.00 = $2.00 per tickStressed initial margin used: 2 × $875 = $1,750
Commission per contract per side: $0.75Stressed initial margin percentage: $1,750 / $10,000 × 100 = 17.5%
Entry commission: 2 × $0.75 = $1.50Stressed simplified free equity: $10,000 - $1,750 = $8,250
Exit commission: 2 × $0.75 = $1.50Reduction in free equity: $8,600 - $8,250 = $350
Round-trip commission: $1.50 + $1.50 = $3.00Maintenance stress convention: No second maintenance increase specified; do not invent one
Simulated account equity: $10,000Margin interpretation: Collateral requirement, not a fixed maximum loss or transaction fee
Written risk policy: 1% of starting equity per tradeGap-risk scenario: Position exits at $69.30 rather than planned stop $69.62
Risk budget: $10,000 × 0.01 = $100Gap movement from actual entry: $69.30 - $70.05 = -$0.75 per barrel
Planned entry ask: $70.02Gap gross P&L: -$0.75 × 100 × 2 = -$150.00
Planned stop exit: $69.62Gap net P&L: -$150 - $3 = -$153.00
Planned target exit: $70.82Gap loss percentage: $153 / $10,000 × 100 = 1.53%
Planned stop distance: ($70.02 - $69.62) / $0.01 = 40 ticksGap loss relative to initial plan: $153 / $83 = 1.843373... ≈ 1.84 times
Planned target distance: ($70.82 - $70.02) / $0.01 = 80 ticksGap loss relative to $100 budget: $153 / $100 = 1.53 times
Planned gross reward-to-risk: 80 / 40 = 2.00Dollar breach of risk budget: $153 - $100 = $53.00
Planned stop-price loss: 40 × $2 = $80.00Stop interpretation: Intended exit, not guaranteed fill or maximum loss
Planned commission-inclusive risk: $80 + $3 = $83.00Five-trade journal size: 5 simulated trades, 2 contracts each
Planned risk percentage: $83 / $10,000 × 100 = 0.83%Trade 1 net result: +$147
Planned target gross: 80 × $2 = +$160.00Trade 2 net result: -$85
Planned target net: $160 - $3 = +$157.00Trade 3 net result: +$62
Observed bid at entry order: $70.00Trade 4 net result: -$89
Observed ask at entry order: $70.02Trade 5 net result: +$31
Observed midpoint: ($70.00 + $70.02) / 2 = $70.01Total net P&L: $147 - $85 + $62 - $89 + $31 = +$66
Quoted spread: $70.02 - $70.00 = $0.02 = 2 ticksAverage net P&L per trade: $66 / 5 = +$13.20
Spread value per contract: 2 × $1 = $2.00Average as percentage of starting equity: $13.20 / $10,000 × 100 = 0.132%
Spread value across position: 2 × $2 = $4.00Winning trades: 3 of 5
Entry half-spread: $70.02 - $70.01 = 1 tickLosing trades: 2 of 5
Entry half-spread versus midpoint: 1 tick × $2 = $2.00Win rate: 3 / 5 × 100 = 60%
First partial fill: 1 contract at $70.04Total winning dollars: $147 + $62 + $31 = $240
Second partial fill: 1 contract at $70.06Average winning trade: $240 / 3 = $80.00
Weighted average entry: (1 × $70.04 + 1 × $70.06) / 2 = $70.05Total losing dollars: $85 + $89 = $174 loss
Entry slippage baseline: Observed ask $70.02 at order submissionAverage losing trade: $174 / 2 = $87.00 loss
Average entry slippage: ($70.05 - $70.02) / $0.01 = 3 ticksSlippage sequence: 3, 1, 2, 3, 0 position ticks
Entry slippage dollars: 3 ticks × $2 = $6.00Total slippage: 3 + 1 + 2 + 3 + 0 = 9 ticks
Spread-versus-slippage distinction: Half-spread references midpoint; slippage references observed askAverage slippage per trade: 9 / 5 = 1.8 ticks
Unchanged intended stop: $69.62Two-contract dollar value per tick: $2.00
Actual-fill-to-stop distance: ($70.05 - $69.62) / $0.01 = 43 ticksFive-trade slippage cost: 9 × $2 = $18.00
Updated stop-price loss: 43 × $2 = $86.00Five-trade commissions: 5 × $3 = $15.00
Updated commission-inclusive risk: $86 + $3 = $89.00Five-trade total measured costs: $18 + $15 = $33.00
Updated risk percentage: $89 / $10,000 × 100 = 0.89%Frictionless comparison before costs: $66 net + $18 slippage + $15 commission = $99.00
Risk increase versus plan: $89 - $83 = $6.00Cost share of frictionless result: $33 / $99 × 100 = 33.333...% ≈ 33.3%
Risk budget remaining: $100 - $89 = $11.00 under exact-stop assumptionsFive-trade interpretation: Too small a sample to establish reliable performance or predict returns
Observed exit bid: $70.82Journal field: dates: Trade date, spec version, margin notice, expiry deadline
Actual market sell fill: $70.80Journal field: original plan: Entry, stop, target, contract count, risk budget, planned P&L
Exit execution shortfall: ($70.82 - $70.80) / $0.01 = 2 ticksJournal field: order-time quote: Bid, ask, midpoint, spread in ticks and time recorded
Exit shortfall dollars: 2 × $2 = $4.00Journal field: actual fills: Partial quantities, execution prices, weighted average
Actual executed price change: $70.80 - $70.05 = +$0.75 per barrelJournal field: cost attribution: Entry slippage, exit shortfall, commission and net P&L
Actual gross P&L: $0.75 × 100 × 2 = +$150.00Journal field: updated risk: Actual-fill stop distance, risk percentage and budget comparison
Actual net P&L: $150 - $3 = +$147.00Journal field: margin: Initial, maintenance, free equity and stress assumptions
Actual net percentage of equity: $147 / $10,000 × 100 = +1.47%Journal field: process review: Rule-following tag, evidence, mistakes, rejected setups and next review
Execution shortfall versus plan: $157 - $147 = $10.00Common mistake: Writing the plan after seeing the outcome
Shortfall decomposition: $6 entry slippage + $4 exit shortfall = $10Common mistake: Failing to retain the quote observed when submitting the order
Gross P&L treatment: Already based on actual fills; do not subtract spread againCommon mistake: Ignoring partial fills when calculating average execution price
All contracts, dates, quotations, fills, margin rules and trading outcomes are fictional. The order-time spread is two ticks, but entry half-spread and entry slippage use different benchmarks and must not be confused. The actual $70.05 entry increases commission-inclusive planned stop risk from $83 to $89. The actual $70.80 exit reduces planned $157 net target profit to $147, with $6 entry slippage and $4 exit shortfall. The April 15 margin notice supersedes older collateral requirements. The separate $69.30 gap case loses $153 net, demonstrating that a stop does not guarantee the $100 risk budget. Across five independent paper trades, net P&L totals $66 and measured slippage plus commissions total $33, or 33.3% of the hypothetical $99 result before those costs. Five trades are insufficient for statistical confidence or predictive claims. No live trading or financial recommendation is involved.

Key terms

  • Journal: a written record of each decision, its plan and its result.
  • Spread: the difference between ask and bid, measured in ticks.
  • Midpoint: the average of the bid and the ask.
  • Slippage: a fill worse than the price seen when the order was sent.
  • Partial fill: an order executed in several parts at different prices.
  • Average fill: the weighted average price of all parts of an order.
  • Execution shortfall: planned result minus actual result caused by execution.
  • Initial margin: the funds required to open a position.
  • Maintenance margin: the lower funds level required to keep a position open.
  • Free equity: equity left after initial margin, before costs and price changes.
  • Gap: a price jump that skips over a stop level.
  • Commission: the fee charged per contract per side.
Multi Asset Trading Lab provides educational information only and does not constitute personalized investment, trading, financial, legal, tax, accounting, commodities, derivatives, brokerage, exchange, clearing or risk-management advice. Sample Micro Oil futures is an entirely fictional teaching product. The specification dated April 1, 2026, margin notice dated April 15, 2026, simulated trade dated April 20, 2026, and last trading day of May 19, 2026 are invented classroom inputs. No real exchange, real contract code, actual fund, broker, market price, trade, exchange notice or real financial product is identified or recommended. All simulated account values, bid and ask quotations, partial fills, trading costs, commissions, stop levels, targets, gap assumptions, margin changes and journal results are fictional. No real-money trading, account opening, futures order, commodity delivery or financial commitment is required or encouraged. The fictional contract represents 100 barrels, has a $0.01 price tick worth $1.00 per contract, and charges $0.75 commission per contract per side. Two contracts therefore represent 200 barrels and have $2.00 of combined gross profit-and-loss sensitivity per tick. These definitions are specific to the invented product and must not be applied to actual oil instruments without checking current official contract specifications. The original fictional specification requires initial margin of $600 and maintenance margin of $540 per contract. The later fictional notice dated April 15 raises the requirements to $700 initial and $630 maintenance. The April 20 simulated trade uses the later requirements. Real contract specifications, collateral rules, maintenance thresholds, broker risk policies and effective dates may change and must be independently verified from applicable official sources. The hypothetical account begins with $10,000 equity and a written risk-per-trade policy of 1%, corresponding to a $100 initial planned-loss budget. The original fictional trade plan buys two contracts at the observed $70.02 ask, uses an intended stop exit at $69.62, and identifies an illustrative target exit at $70.82. The stop distance is $0.40 per barrel, or 40 ticks. With $2 combined price sensitivity per tick, gross intended stop-price loss is $80. The fictional completed round-trip commission is $3, so the initial commission-inclusive planned risk equals $83, or 0.83% of starting equity. The target lies 80 ticks above the entry ask. Its assumed complete fill would produce $160 gross profit and $157 net profit after commission. The planned gross reward-to-price-risk ratio is 2:1. These figures are not trading signals, price forecasts, recommended contract quantities or guaranteed results. They are arithmetic based on stipulated fictional prices and assumed complete executions. The order-time fictional quote is $70.00 bid and $70.02 ask, giving midpoint $70.01 and spread $0.02, or two ticks. The complete bid-ask difference across two contracts is $4. The entry ask is one tick above the midpoint, which corresponds to $2 of midpoint-referenced entry friction. This midpoint-based comparison is distinct from adverse slippage measured against the ask observed when the market buy is submitted. The fictional market buy fills one contract at $70.04 and the other at $70.06, giving a quantity-weighted average entry of $70.05. The actual average is three ticks above the $70.02 observed ask, equivalent to $6 of adverse entry slippage across the two-contract position. This execution shortfall is not a separately billed exchange fee. Gross profit and loss based on actual execution prices already reflect the economic effects of those fills. The originally planned $69.62 stop remains unchanged, making actual-fill-to-stop distance $70.05 minus $69.62, or $0.43 per barrel and 43 ticks. Across two contracts that represents $86 gross stop-price loss. Adding the $3 stipulated round-trip commission produces $89 updated commission-inclusive risk, or 0.89% of starting equity. It is $6 greater than the original $83 planned risk but remains $11 below the written $100 budget under exact-stop assumptions. The original pretrade risk and the updated risk must both be recorded; rewriting the earlier plan to match the realized fill would destroy the audit trail. The fictional exit begins when the displayed bid is $70.82, but the simulated market sell executes at $70.80, two ticks worse. Across two contracts the difference is $4. Actual gross trade profit is ($70.80 - $70.05) multiplied by 200 barrels, or $150. Deducting the $3 round-trip commission produces $147 net profit, or 1.47% of the $10,000 starting equity. The original plan expected $157 net profit, so the actual result is $10 lower. The difference is attributed to $6 adverse entry slippage and $4 adverse exit shortfall. This attribution must not be charged again after the fill-based actual net result has already been calculated. Similarly, the quoted spread must not be deducted separately from gross or net profit calculated using actual executed ask and bid prices, because doing so would double-count execution friction. The entire exercise assumes the fictional quoted prices, displayed references and execution fills are available as described. Real market orders may experience partial fills, changing quotations, spreads, variable liquidity, delays, different execution policies, outright rejection, market impact, trading halts or slippage much larger than the classroom figures. A displayed quote does not guarantee that an order will execute at that price or that the full requested quantity will fill. The journal must distinguish planned entry and exit, observed market quotes, actual partial fills, weighted average execution, explicit commissions, price movement and the difference between intended and realized outcomes. The fictional April 15 notice sets initial margin at $700 and maintenance margin at $630 per contract. For two contracts, current initial margin is $1,400, or 14% of the original $10,000 account, while maintenance margin totals $1,260. Subtracting the current initial requirement from starting equity produces $8,600 of simplified funds before commissions, market profit and loss or other account obligations. The separate hypothetical margin stress assumes an additional 25% increase in initial margin only, raising the per-contract requirement from $700 to $875. For two contracts, required initial margin becomes $1,750, or 17.5% of starting equity, and simplified funds after the requirement decline to $8,250. The resulting $350 reduction illustrates collateral pressure. No additional maintenance margin revision is specified in that stress, so none should be inferred. These simplified free-equity figures do not constitute a promise about actual withdrawable funds or brokerage margin availability. Actual futures accounts may be subject to variation margin, account-level clearing rules, settlement cash flows, margin calls, liquidation requirements, different collateral treatment and other obligations. Margin is collateral supporting financial exposure, not a fee, guaranteed maximum loss or protective stop. The separate gap-risk illustration assumes the two-contract long entered at the actual weighted price of $70.05 closes at $69.30 rather than the intended $69.62 stop. The adverse price difference is $0.75 per barrel, producing $150 gross loss across 200 barrels. After the same $3 round-trip commission, net loss is $153, equal to 1.53% of starting account equity. Relative to the original $83 commission-inclusive planned risk, this is approximately 1.8434 times as large, conventionally displayed as 1.84 times. Relative to the $100 risk budget, it is 1.53 times the allowed amount and exceeds that budget by $53. The example demonstrates that a stop instruction is not a guaranteed execution price or maximum financial loss. Actual losses can exceed these illustrations if spreads widen, prices gap further, markets become illiquid, trading is interrupted, collateral requirements change or broker execution differs. The hypothetical gap is not a prediction, frequency estimate or representation of a historical oil-market event. The separate five-trade fictional journal contains two contracts per trade and net P&L after commission of +$147, -$85, +$62, -$89 and +$31. These sum to +$66, or +$13.20 average per trade. Relative to the original $10,000 account equity, that average represents 0.132%. Three of five trades are positive, giving a sample win rate of 60%. The winning trades total $240, producing average win of $80, while the losing trades have combined magnitude of $174, giving an average loss magnitude of $87. These are descriptive properties of a five-observation fictional sample, not estimates of future win probability or expected strategy returns. The recorded slippage sequence is 3, 1, 2, 3 and 0 ticks, totaling nine ticks, or 1.8 ticks on average per trade. For the aggregate summary, each recorded tick is treated as a combined two-contract execution shortfall worth $2. Total assumed slippage cost is therefore $18. Each of five completed two-contract trades pays $3 round-trip commission, giving $15 commissions in total. Combined specified costs are $33. Adding them back to the $66 total net P&L creates a mechanical frictionless comparison of $99. The $33 combined costs amount to one third, or approximately 33.3%, of that $99 before-cost figure. This mechanical comparison assumes that the stated slippage and commissions are the only costs being removed and that all other simulated outcomes are held constant. It is not an executable profit guarantee, and actual results without such costs cannot be inferred directly. The five-trade journal uses a separate aggregate slippage field; it should not be confused with the full entry-plus-exit execution shortfall of the individually examined first trade unless the scope of the recorded metric is defined. Every journal should clearly state whether slippage reflects entry only, exit only, both sides, or a combined position-level shortfall to ensure meaningful comparisons. The five-trade sample is too small to demonstrate statistical significance, durable profitability, a reliable trading edge, predictive skill, future returns or a dependable win rate. Selectively recording winners, hiding losing trades, changing plans after execution, ignoring rejected setups or applying outdated specifications can further undermine the usefulness of a journal. The stated last trading day is May 19, 2026, which is 29 calendar days after the simulated April 20 trading date. Actual products may have different trading-day calendars, settlement deadlines, notice periods or earlier broker position cutoffs. Expiry and cash or physical settlement requirements must be understood from current official specifications. This course does not assert that completing a journal eliminates market, counterparty, margin, slippage, expiry or delivery risk. The purpose of the exercise is to develop a repeatable procedure for preserving original plans, recording actual fills, reconciling commissions and execution differences, stress-testing assumptions and reviewing whether decisions followed written policies. The earlier XAUUSD contract and sizing lab, Micro Oil demo lab, spread and slippage lessons, and margin and leverage materials support these concepts but do not guarantee safe or profitable execution. The next Risk Review Clinic preparation is an educational exercise about auditing contract specifications, minimum position sizes and slippage assumptions. Nothing in this lesson recommends buying, selling, holding, borrowing against, rolling or trading any actual commodity, futures contract, CFD, option, security or other financial instrument. Every example remains fictional, simulated and strictly educational, without investment advice or price predictions.
Lesson practice

Lesson Checkpoint

Review what you learned and get feedback on your work.

0/20
01What is the primary purpose of keeping the original pretrade plan separate from actual fills?
02How should entry slippage for the fictional market buy be measured?
03What is the correct interpretation of a margin requirement increase?
04What can reasonably be concluded from the fictional five-trade journal?
05Which fields belong in a complete fictional execution journal? Select all that apply.

Select all that apply

06Which statements about the fictional $69.30 gap-stop scenario are correct? Select all that apply.

Select all that apply

07Which calculation correctly measures the weighted average entry and adverse slippage?
Scenario

One fictional micro contract fills at $70.04 and one at $70.06, while the displayed ask when submitting the order was $70.02.

08Which statement correctly reconciles the planned and actual trade outcomes?
Scenario

Planned entry $70.02, planned target exit $70.82, actual weighted entry $70.05, actual exit $70.80, two 100-barrel contracts and $3 total commission.

09Which result correctly follows from the hypothetical additional 25% initial-margin increase?
Scenario

The updated fictional initial margin is $700 per contract, the position contains two contracts, and starting equity is $10,000.

10Identify the incorrect statement about the fictional execution reconciliation.
The market buy averages $70.05, exit fills $70.80, position size is 200 barrels, round-trip commission is $3, and the initial quote was $70.00 bid and $70.02 ask.

Select every line that contains an error

11Fill in the blanks

The difference between the execution price and the displayed quotation used as the order-time reference is called .

12Fill in the blanks

When one order executes at several prices, the combined entry should be recorded using a quantity-weighted price.

13Fill in the blanks

The difference between the planned net result and the actual net result in this lesson is called execution .

14Arrange the steps for creating the fictional micro oil trade journal.

Tap the steps in the correct order

    15Arrange the steps for reconciling actual execution and reviewing the five-trade sample.

    Tap the steps in the correct order

      16Match each trading journal concept to its meaning.
      Specification version
      Margin notice
      Pretrade plan
      Order-time quote
      Bid-ask spread
      Entry half-spread
      Slippage
      Partial fill
      Weighted average fill
      Execution shortfall
      Initial margin
      Maintenance margin
      Gap risk
      Rule-following tag
      Small-sample uncertainty
      17Match each fictional trading journal calculation to its correct result.
      Original specification date
      Margin notice date
      Simulated trade date
      Calendar days to last trading day
      Combined tick value
      Entry quotation spread
      Planned risk
      Planned net target profit
      Weighted average entry
      Entry slippage
      Updated exact-stop risk
      Actual exit fill
      Exit shortfall
      Actual trade net P&L
      Total execution shortfall
      Current initial margin
      Current maintenance margin
      Stressed initial margin
      Stressed simplified free equity
      Gap-stop net P&L
      Five-trade net total
      Five-trade win rate
      Average winning trade
      Average losing trade
      Five-trade slippage costs
      Five-trade commissions
      Frictionless comparison before specified costs
      18A fictional two-contract micro oil market buy receives one fill at $70.04 and one at $70.06. Both fills have equal quantity. Calculate the weighted average entry price.
      USD per barrel
      19Two fictional 100-barrel micro oil contracts enter at weighted average $70.05 and exit at $70.80, with total round-trip commission of $3. Calculate actual net P&L.
      USD
      20Five fictional trades total $66 net after slippage and commission. Recorded slippage costs $18 and commission costs $15. Calculate the frictionless comparison P&L before those two costs.
      USD
      Answered · 0/20